Beyond Tools and Techniques: Rethinking How We Approach Development

Coaching in a Changing Landscape

Coaching is changing. What was once centred on potential and performance is now unfolding in a world that’s not just complex or unpredictable. To borrow Jamais Cascio’s term, it’s BANI — brittle, anxious, nonlinear, and incomprehensible.

If we want to stay fit for purpose, our development needs to be as nuanced and robust as the realities our clients are facing.

Human-to-human coaching is no longer about performance or potential — the “bigger, better, faster” aspirations.
That territory now belongs to AI. Low-cost, automated coaching platforms can already deliver structured conversations, instant feedback, and scalable development. They can replicate the form of coaching remarkably well.

But what they can’t offer is humanity. They can’t hold silence, sense uncertainty, or stay with someone through the discomfort of not knowing. They can’t respond to paradox, emotion, or the subtle shifts that happen when two people think together.

That’s our territory. And it means our own development can’t stay rooted in performance metrics or standardised models. We need to cultivate what no algorithm can replicate, discernment, depth, and self-awareness.

Coaching, at its best, is not about managing goals. It’s about being in a relationship, navigating complexity, ambiguity, and what it means to be human.

Knowing the Rules So We Can Break Them

There’s a phrase often used in the arts: you need to know the rules before you can break them. It applies to coaching as well.

Early in our coaching careers, we learn the craft, the competencies, ethics, and models that underpin good practice. Over time, development becomes less about following and more about understanding. It’s about knowing the purpose behind the rules so we can adapt, improvise, and, when appropriate, transcend them with integrity.

This is where the art of coaching begins — the shift from doing coaching right to being in coaching well.

Karen Foy’s Breaking the Code: How Great Coaches Transcend the Rules beautifully touches on this, describing how great coaches draw on the foundations of their craft while refusing to be constrained by them. That same curiosity sits at the heart of my research into coach development — where growth is less about learning new tools and more about expanding our awareness of how we think, make meaning, and show up.

“Equipping is technical. Preparing is developmental.”

Beyond CPD: From Apps to System Upgrades

Traditional CPD often focuses on adding more tools, more models, more credentials. These are the apps of our profession. They help, but only up to a point.

A holistic approach to development, CPPD, continual personal and professional development, is not about adding more. It’s about upgrading the system that runs those apps: our awareness, biases, and capacity for stillness in the face of uncertainty.

This isn’t about getting better at doing coaching. It’s about becoming someone who can be with more complexity.

That means developing both capability and capacity —the skills we use and the self we bring. A coach who is technically skilled but internally depleted can’t meet the moment. Development that deepens both competence and consciousness is what keeps our practice alive.

Development as Progress, Not Reaching Perfection

We often imagine development as linear: learn something, apply it, move up a level. But human growth is rarely like that. It’s cyclical. Sometimes we advance; sometimes we return to our roots.

You can’t make a tree grow by pulling at it. What you can do is nurture the conditions, water the soil, ensure the light, and protect it when the weather turns.

The same applies to us. We can’t force development through endless striving. We can, however, create the right conditions through supervision, reflection, dialogue, and rest.
Growth happens not when we push harder, but when we engage more consciously with what’s shaping us.

From Reflection to Critical Reflexivity

The next evolution in how we develop as coaches is moving from reflection to critical reflexivity.

Reflection asks: “What did I do well, or not well?”
Critical reflexivity asks: “How am I making sense of what’s happening here? What’s influencing how I show up?”

That shift takes us beyond improving performance to expanding awareness. It challenges the assumptions we inherit from our training, organisations, or culture.

For example:

  • Reflective: “That session felt flat. I should have asked a more powerful question.”
  • Critically reflexive: “Why was I so focused on making the session feel impactful? What does ‘impact’ mean to me — and where did I learn that?”

Critical reflexivity doesn’t transform us, but it fosters the awareness that makes development possible — helping us notice where we’re operating from habit rather than awareness and re-author our practice from a more conscious place.

Practical Reflections for Coaches

If we take this seriously, it changes how we approach development.

Prioritise CPPD that includes:

  • Supervision that invites critical reflexivity
  • Personal development that sustains your humanity
  • Boundary work and rest that protect your capacity to think clearly

Ask yourself:

  • “Am I developing to perform, or to be?”
  • “What’s resourcing me, not just credentialing me?”
  • “Am I strengthening my roots, or just polishing my branches?”

Closing Reflection

Coaching is evolving, and so must we. Our development can’t be about perfecting the craft. It must be about deepening the human behind it.

As AI learns to coach, we must keep learning to be. That means development that:

  • Builds capacity, not just competence
  • Helps us hold paradox and uncertainty
  • Enables critical reflexivity, not just reflection
  • Strengthens who we are, not just what we know

In the end, it’s the difference between decorating the tree and tending to the roots, the quiet, unseen work that keeps everything alive.

If this resonates, you can explore how I work with coaches and supervisors to create reflective, developmental spaces at eacrosse.co.uk.

about elizabeth
Elizabeth is a supervisor, mentor, coach and researcher who explores the complexities of coaching and professional development. Blending evidence-based insights with practical relevance, she invites you to think deeply, consider different perspectives, and stay open to what might emerge.
Follow on on Linkedin

Did you enjoy this? Here are other articles you may like

If you’re prepared to take the next step of your learning journey, I’m here to support and challenge you.

Together, we will explore your thinking, current perspectives, and new ideas as you cultivate the practical wisdom necessary to enhance your professional practice. The potential for personal and professional development is immense, and I would love to be a part of your journey.